‍

Ever stopped in your tracks and wondered, "Why on earth is this thing so popular?" Well, you're not alone. That's the million-dollar question that marketers, creators, and innovators have been asking themselves since... well, forever.

Popularity is the enigmatic party guest who's always surrounded by a crowd, leaving everyone else scratching their heads and asking, "What's their secret?" It’s a fickle beast. One day it lavishes its charms on fidget spinners, the next it’s all about the newest vegan milk alternative. But what if we told you there's more method to this madness than you might think?

In this article, we're going to don our Sherlock Holmes hats and dig into the secret life of popularity. This isn't your run-of-the-mill marketing spiel - we're getting down to the nitty-gritty, cutting through the hype and dissecting what makes something catch on.

Is it just about being shiny and new, or is there a more profound psychological game at play?

The Popularity Paradox: Balancing Familiarity and Novelty

Humans, as you well know, are a bundle of contradictions. We're thrill-seekers and homebodies, innovators and traditionalists. In the world of popularity, this paradox translates into our love for the new and the old. We're like magpies attracted to shiny objects, but at the same time, we take comfort in the familiar.

This idea of familiarity, or “fluency” as the smart folks call it, is a biggie. Picture this: You're scrolling through Netflix, looking for a movie to watch. Do you pick the one with an unfamiliar story, or the one that seems like an old friend? Most likely, it's the latter. The same goes for music, design, you name it. If something tickles our familiarity fancy, we're more likely to enjoy it. It's like a cognitive comfort food, and who doesn't love comfort food, right?

But wait, there's a twist! Just as you can have too much pizza (controversial, I know), you can also have too much familiarity. If the story is too predictable, the song too repetitive, it's a big turn off. Here's where our thrill-seeker side kicks in. We want a sprinkling of surprise, a dash of unpredictability.

“You take twenty-five things that are in any successful genre, and you reverse one of them… like a classic western adventure story, but set in space.” - Hit Makers by Derek Thompson

Enter the concept of 'Most Advanced Yet Acceptable' (or MAYA, if you're into the whole brevity thing). This principle is all about balancing novelty with familiarity. It's the Goldilocks of design, not too hot, not too cold, just right. Think of it as that perfect bowl of porridge - familiar enough to be comforting, yet exciting enough to make you go "Mmm… this is interesting!"

So what's the takeaway here? Well, if you're looking to win the popularity game, you've got to be a bit of a tightrope walker, balancing the old and the new. Sure, familiarity might be the key to our hearts, but don't be afraid to shake things up a little. Give your audience that 'aha' moment they didn't even know they were looking for.

The Myth of Virality: The Underrated Power of Distribution

Now, let's bust a myth that's been doing the rounds. You've probably heard it a million times - create something 'viral', and you're set. Sit back, relax, and watch your idea spread like wildfire. Sounds dreamy, right? Well, hate to break it to you, but it's a load of baloney.

See, true virality, where a million individual moments lead to a hit, is rarer than a unicorn sighting. What actually happens is more akin to a game of Chinese Whispers, where a few key players shout your message from the rooftops and it trickles down to the masses. These folks, let's call them 'dark broadcasters', are the secret weapon in your arsenal.

Think about the last viral video you watched. Was it a result of a million people sharing it individually? Not likely. Instead, it probably got a signal boost from a pop star, a celebrity, or a major broadcaster. These are your dark broadcasters.

Another nifty trick is to leverage existing networks or 'clusters'. Think about how Facebook or Tinder first took over college campuses before conquering the world. They used what’s known as a "bowling pin strategy", knocking over one tightly packed group before moving on to the next. It's about finding that sweet spot where your idea or product resonates, then letting the magic happen.

So, remember, it's not just about creating something 'infectious'. It's about knowing where to throw the pebble to create the biggest ripples. Find your dark broadcasters, tap into those clusters, and let them do the heavy lifting for you.

Deciphering Desire: Predicting What People Want

This brings us to our final puzzle piece - figuring out what the heck people want. If we could do that accurately, we'd all be on a beach in Tahiti, sipping cocktails from a coconut. But, as you're well aware, people are complicated creatures. Their desires are a tangled web of contradictions and unknowns.

There are three sides to this coin: what people say they want (stated preference), what they actually do (revealed preference), and what they don't even know they want yet (latent preference). Navigating this trinity is like trying to read a map in a language you don't understand, but stick with me.

The challenge is to appeal to both our aspirational selves (who we want to be) and our actual selves (who we are). We want to be the person who reads hard news and enlightening articles, but more often than not, we're the person scrolling through funny cat videos.

So, how do we reconcile these conflicting desires? Well, it's a bit of a balancing act. We need to offer people what they reliably want while also giving them the opportunity to be surprised, to discover that they love something they didn't even know they wanted.

The key is to not just rely on surveys or research data. While they can provide valuable insights, they need to be complemented with good ol' human judgement, intuition, and a willingness to experiment.

So, there you have it - It's not about jumping on the latest fad or following the crowd. It's about understanding our complex human nature, playing with the balance between the new and the familiar, harnessing the power of networks, and constantly challenging ourselves to surprise and delight.

Now, go out there and create something that will make people go, "Hey, this is interesting!"